The Trolley Problem and Risk Management – Do You Sacrifice One Trade to Save the Portfolio?

Picture this. You’re managing a portfolio. One position; let’s say a biotech stock which is plummeting. Down 25%, 30%, maybe more. The rest of your holdings are still healthy. But this one loser is dragging your overall performance into the red.

You hesitate. If you cut it now, the loss is realized. But the rest of your portfolio is protected. If you hold, maybe it rebounds… or maybe it collapses further, threatening everything else.

Welcome to the Trolley Problem; portfolio edition.

What Is the Trolley Problem?

The classic Trolley Problem is a moral thought experiment in ethics: 

A runaway trolley is heading toward five people tied to a track. You can pull a lever to divert it onto another track, but on that track, one person is tied down. Do you do nothing and let five people die? Or pull the lever and sacrifice one to save the five?

It’s a painful choice between action vs. inaction, individual vs. collective, and intention vs. outcome. Now let’s translate that into investing.

The Trader’s Trolley

In markets, you're constantly faced with versions of this dilemma: one position is losing, but you still believe in the thesis. 

Cutting it would improve your risk profile, reduce stress, and protect the whole. But selling it feels like betrayal. Admission of failure. What if it rebounds? The question becomes:

Do you “sacrifice” one position to save your portfolio?

Or do you let it continue, hoping the market proves you right, and risk it dragging everything down with it?

Emotional Leverage: The Real Risk

What makes this so difficult isn’t the numbers, it’s the psychology:

• Regret Aversion: You fear cutting the loser and watching it bounce back.

• Ego Attachment: Selling feels like being wrong. Holding feels like staying “in control.”

• Sunk Cost Fallacy: You’ve held it this long, shouldn’t you give it more time?

• Hero Complex: You want to be the one who held through the pain and won.

But in trying to save one trade, you may expose the entire portfolio to greater risk.

Portfolio Management Is Triage

In medicine, triage means prioritizing care to save as many lives as possible, not necessarily every life. In investing, it’s the same:

You protect the system, not every position.

That means sometimes you cut a loser not because the idea was wrong, but because it’s costing too much to keep hoping. Risk management is often not about being right, it’s about staying solvent.

Your first loss is your best loss.

Strategic Levers in the Trolley Problem 

So how do you decide when to “pull the lever”? Here are five mental models to help:

1. Predefined Stop-Losses
Treat them as the moral boundary you won’t cross. If the stock hits a certain % loss, you pull the lever. No hesitation.

2. Portfolio Impact Over Trade Identity
Don’t ask, “Is this trade worth saving?” Ask, “What happens to the portfolio if I keep it?”

3. Position Sizing as Risk Buffer
If you sized it properly, a single loser shouldn’t wreck the whole. Use size as your first line of defense.

4. Opportunity Cost Framing
What could your capital be doing elsewhere? Sticking with a flailing position might mean missing something better.

5. Scenario Planning
Model the best-case and worst-case scenarios. Are you truly prepared for the worst?

Ethical Investing or Strategic Sacrifice?

Some investors take a “let no position die” approach, especially if the asset reflects values, loyalty, or long-term vision.

But sometimes, being ethical to your capital means knowing when to let go. Letting one position burn in the name of protecting the greater whole isn't cold-hearted, it's strategic stewardship. You’re not just pulling a lever. You’re steering a train.

Final Reflection: The Cost of Inaction

In moral philosophy, there’s often no perfect answer to the Trolley Problem. But in investing, the answer is usually simpler: 

Cut the loss. Protect the system. Survive to play another day.

You’ll rarely regret a decision that was made with discipline and risk control. You’ll often regret letting hope ride a runaway trolley. So next time you’re staring at that bleeding position, ask:

• What’s the opportunity cost?

• What’s the portfolio impact?

• Am I protecting one idea… or protecting the whole?

Because in the end, being a good investor often means pulling the lever.

Ever struggled to cut a losing position? Drop your trolley dilemma stories in the comments.

Stay up to date by subscribing to my Newsletter.