The Ship of Theseus and Portfolio Management – When You Rebalance, Is It Still the Same Portfolio?

Imagine a ship sailing the seas, weathering storms, growing older. Over time, its wooden planks begin to rot and are replaced, one by one. Eventually, every piece of the ship has been swapped out. Not a single original part remains.

Is it still the same ship?

This is the ancient Greek paradox known as the Ship of Theseus. But it’s more than a philosophical puzzle; it's a perfect metaphor for portfolio management.

Because if you rebalance your portfolio over time; selling winners, trimming losers, reallocating into different assets, at what point does it stop being the portfolio you originally built? Let’s explore.

What Is Rebalancing, Really?

Rebalancing is the process of realigning your portfolio back to its target allocation. Maybe you started with 60% stocks and 40% bonds, but after a bull run, you're at 75/25. Rebalancing means selling some stocks and buying more bonds to bring it back in line. It's a mechanical, seemingly simple task.

But over time, the implications are more complex. You're slowly replacing components of your portfolio; old positions phased out, new ones phased in. Over the years, nothing may remain of the original portfolio you once built.

Which brings us back to the question,

Is it still the same portfolio?

Identity in Transition: What Makes a Portfolio "Yours"?

When you build a portfolio, you’re not just allocating capital; you’re expressing values. Your beliefs about the market. Your goals. Your tolerance for risk. But as life changes, so do those inputs.

   You get older.
   Your goals shift.
   The world evolves.
   New asset classes emerge.
   New risks appear.

Rebalancing isn’t just maintenance; it’s evolution. It’s your portfolio adapting to a changing reality. Just like the Ship of Theseus, it may look similar from the outside, but underneath, everything has changed. And yet… it still belongs to you. Not because of what it holds, but because of why it was built.

The Illusion of Permanence in Finance

There’s a romantic idea of the “forever” portfolio. Buy and hold. Set it and forget it. But even the most hands-off investor must eventually adapt.

   Asset correlations shift.
   Interest rates change.
   Tax laws evolve.
   Your needs don’t stay static.

If you never rebalance, your portfolio may drift into dangerous territory. Over-concentration. Risk misalignment. Exposure to sectors you never intended to bet on. So ironically, the only way to maintain your portfolio’s purpose is to constantly update its parts. Just like Theseus’ ship.

Behavioral Bias Meets Identity

There’s also a psychological layer here. Investors often get attached to specific holdings; stocks they’ve held for years, ETFs they bought during a market crash, even losing positions they don’t want to let go of “just yet.” This attachment can blur judgment. You begin to identify your portfolio not by its structure or function, but by its components.

But just as a person isn’t defined by their clothes, a portfolio isn’t defined by its individual tickers. It’s defined by how well it serves its intended purpose. Letting go is not losing identity. It’s maintaining it.

So… Is It Still the Same Portfolio?

Here’s one answer,

Yes, if its core purpose remains intact.

Just like a ship rebuilt plank by plank can still serve its journey, a portfolio that evolves can still serve its owner, perhaps even better than before.

And here’s another answer,

No, because everything is in flux.

But maybe that’s not a problem. Maybe the goal isn’t to preserve the portfolio’s original form, but to let it change as you do, while keeping its mission aligned with who you are. Because, in the end, a portfolio is not an object; it’s a process.

A Zen Twist on the Paradox

From a Zen perspective, identity is fluid. The self is not fixed. Neither is your portfolio.

Clinging to what it used to be creates suffering.
Accepting what it’s becoming creates peace.

Your portfolio is not a frozen statue; it’s a river. Always moving, yet always there.

Practical Takeaways

Rebalancing is necessary
It’s not betrayal... it’s alignment. Update your portfolio as your life and the market evolve.
Detach from individual holdings
Don’t define your portfolio by what’s inside it. Define it by what it’s designed to do.
Embrace evolution
The best portfolios aren’t preserved. They’re refined.

Final Reflection

When you rebalance your portfolio over time, you change it; piece by piece, step by step. But if you’re doing it with intention, clarity, and purpose, then it’s still your portfolio.

Not because of what it’s made of, but because of what it’s made for. Just like the Ship of Theseus… What truly matters is not the wood or nails, but the journey it carries you on.

Want to go deeper? Share your thoughts in the comments: When you change your investments, are you changing your identity as an investor? Or… are you just updating the ship to keep it seaworthy?

Stay up to date by subscribing to my Newsletter.