The Fermi Paradox and Alpha – If Outperformance Exists, Where Is Everybody?

In the 1950s, physicist Enrico Fermi asked a simple, unsettling question:

If the universe is so vast and old, and intelligent life is possible, then… where is everybody?

This became known as the Fermi Paradox; the tension between high probability and low evidence.

Now take that question and point it toward the markets: if alpha (consistent market outperformance) exists, then where are all the investors who can prove it?

The Alpha Paradox

Every investor wants to believe in alpha. The strategy, the edge, the secret that beats the market.

• Hedge funds spend billions hunting it.

• Analysts write endless reports about it.

• Retail traders chase it through signals and systems.

And yet, much like extraterrestrial civilizations, documented, repeatable alpha is strangely absent. If markets are full of bright minds, powerful computers, and endless strategies… then why don’t we see more consistent winners?

Possible Explanations (The Fermi-Style Answers)

1. The Great Filter: Alpha Gets Arbitraged Away

Maybe alpha does exist, but the moment it’s discovered, competition destroys it. Just like civilizations that collapse before they can spread, strategies die young.

2. We’re Looking in the Wrong Places

Perhaps alpha isn’t in chart patterns or technical signals, but in patience, discipline, and behavior. We might be searching for aliens with radio telescopes when they’re communicating in light.

3. Survivorship Bias: The Few That Exist Don’t Last

Some funds do outperform, but rarely over decades. The ones that make headlines are the exceptions, not the rule. Over time, cycles wash them out.

4. We Are the Aliens: Maybe You’re the Edge
If everyone assumes alpha is impossible, then the contrarian who finds it quietly won’t broadcast it. Just like advanced civilizations might avoid contact, alpha-holders may choose silence.

Markets as a Self-Correcting Universe

The Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) argues that outperformance shouldn’t persist because markets quickly price in information. In other words, every discovery is temporary, like a shooting star in the sky.

And yet, anomalies still appear: momentum, value premiums, volatility inefficiencies. But once they’re discovered and widely known, they fade. The market is like a cosmic censor, erasing traces of alpha before they can spread too far.

The Investor’s Dilemma

So, what does this mean for us?

• Should we stop searching for alpha altogether?

• Should we embrace passive investing as the default?

• Or should we keep exploring, knowing that most strategies burn out but a rare few survive?

Maybe the real paradox is that we must act as if alpha exists to keep the market dynamic, even if it hides like distant civilizations in the stars.

How to Invest Amid the Paradox

1. Respect Efficiency, But Stay Curious
Assume markets are hard to beat, but don’t stop asking questions. Edges might be rare, but curiosity builds resilience.

2. Focus on Process, Not Prediction 
If alpha is elusive, the next best thing is repeatable discipline. Risk control is a form of survival.

3. Differentiate Yourself 
If alpha exists, it may lie in areas others ignore: niche markets, alternative data, or simply patience in a world of noise.

4. Accept Impermanence
Just like civilizations rise and fall, strategies have lifecycles. Don’t worship edges, adapt when they fade.

Final Reflection

The Fermi Paradox forces us to ask: If they’re out there, why don’t we see them? The Alpha Paradox does the same. If outperformance is real, why can’t we consistently find it?

Maybe the truth is unsettling:

• Alpha exists, but only briefly.

• Alpha exists, but not where we expect.

• Or alpha exists, but by the time you discover it, it’s already gone.

So the investor must choose: to keep searching the stars, or to build a strategy that survives in the absence of aliens. Because in markets, as in the cosmos, silence might be the loudest answer.

Stay up to date by subscribing to my Newsletter.